The Economic Fallacies of Black Friday: 2020 Edition

Tomorrow, shoppers across America will participate in the largest shopping day of the year: Black Friday. The National Retail Foundation usually releases an estimate of how many customers will be shopping during the five-day weekend from Thanksgiving Day to Cyber Monday, but the usual crowds are cause for great concern with a resurgent Wēnyì casting a dark shadow over this year’s holiday shopping season. In 2019, there was an estimated consumer base of 165.3 million shoppers[1], with an actual result of 189.6 million.[2] Given the circumstances, it is difficult to guess how many there will be this year.

The usual holiday season forecast that the NRF releases on October 3 was not released, as National Retail Federation Chief Economist Jack Kleinhenz described the effort as “assembling a jigsaw puzzle without all the pieces.” He said on October 1,

“Completing a puzzle is highly probable given patience, having all the pieces and having the picture on the box to guide assembly. But it’s not the same when attempting to fit pieces of the economy together in today’s environment. Many of the pieces are missing.

We are waiting for new data and are still assembling puzzle pieces for the 2020 holiday season. I am cautiously optimistic about the fourth quarter in terms of the economy and consumer spending, but the outlook is clouded with uncertainty pivoting on COVID-19 infection rates. The recession appears to be behind us and the re-opening of the economy over the past several months has created momentum that should carry through the fourth quarter. The test is whether consumer spending will be sustained amid wildcard puzzle pieces including policy surprises, the election and a resurgent virus.”[3]

The NRF estimated that total sales for the 2019 holiday season would be between $727.9 billion and $730.7 billion, a growth of 3.8 to 4.2 percent from 2018[4], with an actual result of $730.2 billion or 4.1 percent growth.[5] This year’s estimate was released belatedly on November 23, and is between $755.3 billion and $766.7 billion, an increase of between 3.6 and 5.2 percent.[6] Applying last year’s statistics to this year, we may expect total sales of $764.7 billion. The NRF estimates that retailers will hire between 475,000 and 575,000 seasonal employees, compared with the actual 562,000 they hired during the 2019 holiday season versus an estimate of 530,000 and 590,000.[4,6] We may therefore expect that retailers will actually hire about 528,300 seasonal employees.

On the surface, this may appear to be a marvelous celebration of free market capitalism. But let us look deeper through the lenses of the broken window fallacy and the idea of malinvestment. To view Black Friday shopping as a boost to the economy ignores the fact that people could either be spending that money in other ways or saving it. In other words, such an approach is an example of the broken window fallacy because it focuses only on what is seen and ignores opportunity costs. If people would save their money rather than spending it on various holiday gifts, then this money would be invested in one thing or another. As Henry Hazlitt explains in Chapter 23 of Economics in One Lesson, saving is really just another form of spending, and one that has a greater tendency to allocate resources where they are most needed.

Per capita spending is predicted to be $997.79 in 2020[7], down from the 2019 estimate of $1,047.83.[8] The above problems get even worse if people use credit cards to spend money that they do not currently have. With a current credit card interest rate of 16.02 percent and a minimum payment of 4.0 percent, a debt of $997.79 would take 5 years and 6 months to pay off and would cost $1,394.10. This is $396.31 wasted on interest payments that could have been kept in one’s accounts or put toward a productive purpose. In 2019, the credit card interest rate was 17.44 percent, and the average debt of $1,047.83 took 5 years and 11 months to pay off with a total cost of $1,526.20.[9]

When people purchase unwanted gifts and/or buy gifts with money they do not currently have, their choices encourage malinvestments. A malinvestment is an investment in a line of production that is mistaken in terms of the real demands of the economy, which leads to wasted capital and economic losses. The holiday shopping season contains a subset of shopping which creates systematic and widespread mistakes in investment and production. However, the effect is not as severe as what occurs during an Austrian business cycle bust and is both caused and resolved in fundamentally different ways. A look at the average monthly returns on the Standard and Poor’s 500 shows that the holiday season is strong for stocks, with November and December being the best months for investments. But January and March are middling, while the average February has losses. (April is likely higher due to income tax returns providing an artificial economic boost.)

With these arguments in mind, would we all be better off if we canceled Black Friday, or even the entire holiday shopping season? It is an open question, but the Austrian School of economics suggests that we could have a better economy if the burst of economic activity in late November and December were spread throughout the year and people did not spend money they do not have on items they do not need.

References

  1. McGinty, Mary (2019, Nov. 15). “More than 165 million people expected to shop over five-day Thanksgiving weekend”. National Retail Federation.
  2. (2019, Dec. 3). “Thanksgiving weekend draws nearly 190 million shoppers, spending up 16 percent”. National Retail Federation.
  3. Shearman, J. Craig (2020, Oct. 1). “NRF chief economist ‘cautiously optimistic’ but says holiday sales will hinge on ‘wildcard puzzle pieces’”. National Retail Federation.
  4. Shearman, J. Craig (2019, Oct. 3). “NRF forecasts holiday sales will grow between 3.8 and 4.2 percent”. National Retail Federation.
  5. (2020, Jan. 16). “NRF says 2019 holiday sales were up 4.1 percent”. National Retail Federation.
  6. Shearman, J. Craig (2020, Nov. 23). “NRF expects holiday sales will grow between 3.6 and 5.2 percent”. National Retail Federation.
  7. Inman, Danielle (2020, Oct. 21). “Consumers Prioritize Spending on Family, Friends Ahead of Holiday Season”. National Retail Federation.
  8. McGinty, Mary (2019, Oct. 24). “Holiday shoppers plan to spend 4 percent more this year”. National Retail Federation.
  9. Maximus, Nullus (2019, Nov. 29). “The Economic Fallacies of Black Friday: 2019 Edition”. Zeroth Position.

<<On Being Suspended From Twitter++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++An Analysis of Cancel Culture>>